When discussing the history of the United States, there are certain topics which are touched on continuously. The Great Depression is one such topic. Its’ cause is controversial to say the least. Some believe that the Great Depression was caused by the failure of the free market and resolved by government intervention. Others believe the opposite: that the Great Depression was caused by government intervention and resolved by the free market. I side with the latter belief.
Before the Great Depression, there had been continuous ups and downs in the market. Each down resolved itself within a couple years and never had any lasting effect. Such should have been the case with the Great Depression. However, as soon as the government intervened, the economy took a turn for the worst as is shown in the following facts: In 1926, the residential real estate peaked. In 1928, the federal government increased interest rates to slow down the stock market. In June of 1929, industrial production dropped sharply which was followed by the Great Crash five months later in October. Here we get the first evidence that Federal intervention was the cause of the Great Depression.
Hoover, sworn into office in March of 1929, was later confronted “during [Roosevelt’s] campaign, [when he] blasted Hoover for spending and taxing too much, boosting the national debt, choking off trade, and putting millions on the dole. He accused the president of ‘reckless and extravagant’ spending, of thinking ‘that we ought to center control of everything in Washington as rapidly as possible,’ and of presiding over ‘the greatest spending administration in peacetime in all of history’” (Lawrence Reed, The Great Myths of the Great Depression).
However, as much as Roosevelt pounded Hoover for government intervention, when Roosevelt was elected president, government policies didn’t change much. Rexford Guy Tugwell, an agricultural economist and a member of Roosevelt’s Brain-trust, said, “We didn’t admit it at the time, but practically the whole New Deal was extrapolated from programs that Hoover started.”
In the first one hundred days of Roosevelt’s administration, the following were proposed to congress and passed: the Emergency Banking Relief Act, the Economy Act, the Civilian Conservation Corps Reforestation Act, The Beer-Whine Revenue Act, The Removal of the Gold Standard, The Federal Emergency Relief Act, the Agricultural Adjustment Act, the Tennessee Valley Authority, the Federal Securities Act, Congress cancels contractual requirements for gold payments, National Employment Act, the Home Owners Refinancing Act, the Banking Act of 1933, the Farm Credit Act the Emergency Railroad Transportation Act, the National Industrial Recovery Act.
This list contains sixteen different government interventions overseen by Roosevelt. Roosevelt finally realized that the government intervention was too much during his second term in office and cut back on the government policies passing only two acts. From there, the economy slowly fixed itself. Half way through his second term and at the end of the Great Depression in 1939, the American Institute of Public Opinion took a poll of the general public posing the following question: “Do you think the attitude of the Roosevelt administration towards business is delaying business recovery?” 80% of the population voted and of those, 67.5% voted yes.
During World War II, in November of 1941 Fortune took a poll of business executives and asked: “Which of the following comes closest to being your prediction of the kind of economic structure with which this country will emerge after the war?” The answers included a system of free enterprise, a semi-socialized system, a complete dictatorship along fascist or communist lines, and an economic system taken over by the government with some freedom. In order, the percentage of votes for each answer was 7.2%, 36.7%, 3.7%, and 52.4%. Off of what happened after WWI, 92.8% of the population believed that the government would seize control of the economy in one way or another.
Government intervention has become a fear of the people. The Great Depression tells the story of the price of government intervention. Its’ legacy is fear of government control. Given these facts and many others that I did not mention, I believe that the intervention of the federal government caused the great depression and the free market resolved the issue.
Nice work- solid evidence, thorough coverage of the topic.
ReplyDeleteI liked your essay. I could tell that you did your research. Good job.
ReplyDeleteyour essay had a lot of good facts. I think it could have been a little more specific though about the individual acts.
ReplyDelete