Monday, November 28, 2011

The Government and the Great Depression

When discussing the history of the United States, there are certain topics which are touched on continuously. The Great Depression is one such topic. Its’ cause is controversial to say the least. Some believe that the Great Depression was caused by the failure of the free market and resolved by government intervention. Others believe the opposite: that the Great Depression was caused by government intervention and resolved by the free market. I side with the latter belief.

Before the Great Depression, there had been continuous ups and downs in the market. Each down resolved itself within a couple years and never had any lasting effect. Such should have been the case with the Great Depression. However, as soon as the government intervened, the economy took a turn for the worst as is shown in the following facts: In 1926, the residential real estate peaked. In 1928, the federal government increased interest rates to slow down the stock market. In June of 1929, industrial production dropped sharply which was followed by the Great Crash five months later in October. Here we get the first evidence that Federal intervention was the cause of the Great Depression.

Hoover, sworn into office in March of 1929, was later confronted “during [Roosevelt’s] campaign, [when he] blasted Hoover for spending and taxing too much, boosting the national debt, choking off trade, and putting millions on the dole.  He accused the president of ‘reckless and extravagant’ spending, of thinking ‘that we ought to center control of everything in Washington as rapidly as possible,’ and of presiding over ‘the greatest spending administration in peacetime in all of history’” (Lawrence Reed, The Great Myths of the Great Depression).

However, as much as Roosevelt pounded Hoover for government intervention, when Roosevelt was elected president, government policies didn’t change much. Rexford Guy Tugwell, an agricultural economist and a member of Roosevelt’s Brain-trust, said, “We didn’t admit it at the time, but practically the whole New Deal was extrapolated from programs that Hoover started.”

In the first one hundred days of Roosevelt’s administration, the following were proposed to congress and passed: the Emergency Banking Relief Act, the Economy Act, the Civilian Conservation Corps Reforestation Act, The Beer-Whine Revenue Act, The Removal of the Gold Standard, The Federal Emergency Relief Act, the Agricultural Adjustment Act,  the Tennessee Valley Authority, the Federal Securities Act, Congress cancels contractual requirements for gold payments, National Employment Act, the Home Owners Refinancing Act, the Banking Act of 1933, the Farm Credit Act the Emergency Railroad Transportation Act, the National Industrial Recovery Act.

This list contains sixteen different government interventions overseen by Roosevelt. Roosevelt finally realized that the government intervention was too much during his second term in office and cut back on the government policies passing only two acts. From there, the economy slowly fixed itself. Half way through his second term and at the end of the Great Depression in 1939, the American Institute of Public Opinion took a poll of the general public posing the following question:  “Do you think the attitude of the Roosevelt administration towards business is delaying business recovery?” 80% of the population voted and of those, 67.5% voted yes.

During World War II, in November of 1941 Fortune took a poll of business executives and asked: “Which of the following comes closest to being your prediction of the kind of economic structure with which this country will emerge after the war?” The answers included a system of free enterprise, a semi-socialized system, a complete dictatorship along fascist or communist lines, and an economic system taken over by the government with some freedom. In order, the percentage of votes for each answer was 7.2%, 36.7%, 3.7%, and 52.4%. Off of what happened after WWI, 92.8% of the population believed that the government would seize control of the economy in one way or another.

Government intervention has become a fear of the people. The Great Depression tells the story of the price of government intervention. Its’ legacy is fear of government control. Given these facts and many others that I did not mention, I believe that the intervention of the federal government caused the great depression and the free market resolved the issue.

Thursday, November 10, 2011

My Chartered City

Around the world there are many different types of social and economic systems. These systems combine to make the government. If asked to create a city in an uninhabited part of the world with its own set of rules, the person would more often than not keep the governmental system they have and change a few of the flaws it has. However, that is not the case with me. While I believe that the principles that are the foundation of the American government are correct, I do not necessarily agree with the government as a whole. Perhaps this sounds like a “Molly Mormon” thing to say, but it’s the truth: if I were to choose a system of government to rule my remote city, it would be United Order. The three main principles of my city would be Life, Liberty, and Property. However, for the United Order to be able to function, each of these principles must be founded on an even greater one: Charity, the pure love of Christ.

The United Order is often confused with Socialism. This is an incorrect comparison. In order to right it, a definition must be found for both. Socialism is defined by the Webster’s International Dictionary as: "A political and economic theory of social organization based on collective or governmental ownership and democratic management of the essential means for the production and distribution of goods; also, a policy or practice based on this theory." The United Order can be defined as Elder Marion G. Romney of the Council of the Twelve Apostles put so aptly in his 1966 spring General Conference address:

On January 2, 1831, the Lord revealed to the Prophet Joseph Smith that the Church was under obligation to care for the poor. (See D&C 38.) Later he said:

"I, the Lord, stretched out the heavens, and built the earth, . . .and all things therein are mine.

"And it is my purpose to provide for my saints, for all things are mine.

"But it must needs be done in mine own way. . . ." (D&C 104:14-16.)

Consecration and stewardship

On February 9, 1831, the Lord revealed to the Prophet what his way was. (See D&C 42.) In his way there were two cardinal principles: (1) consecration and (2) stewardship.

The main difference between the two systems is Charity. The people willingly give what they truly do not need to the government. From there, the government stores and redistributes what is necessary to those who truly are in need. Life, Liberty, and Property still apply. The people have stewardship, to use Elder Romney’s phrasing, over their Property and willingly consecrate, or give up, that Property to the church. This insures that the people have Liberty because they are giving of their Property out of free will and Charity. This in turn insures the life of everyone because everyone is giving and everyone is receiving. To quote the video Greed, some believe that greed is a good thing and that it helps to move the economy and the country along. However, if we replace that greed with Charity, not only will the economy and country improve, but the final result will be all the better because of the reason behind the act. In other words, the people don’t act in Charity because they can but rather because it’s right. This is the true strength of Charity and the United Order. Life, Liberty and Property are protected through acts of Charity.

Friday, October 14, 2011

The Federalist No. 51 and the Constitution

The United States was founded upon the ideals of men, particularly that of liberty; those men who instigated this nation have been given the title of the Founding Fathers. One of these men principle to to brining about liberty was James Madion. In The Federalist No. 51, he states, "In framing a government which is to be administered by men over men, the great difficulty lies in this: you must first enable the government to control the governed; and in the next place oblige it to control itself." This statement creates a paradox.

The first part of this is that government it created to administer and rule men by puting others over men. This is also known as what Madison refers to as the "primary control" or more commonly termed as popular sovereignty. In other words, the government is directly dependent on the people as the people give the government its power and thus have the ability to take that power away. In effect, this gives the governed more power then the government. The second part is that the government must not only govern the people but itself as well. This is refered to as "auxiliary precautions" or what is more commonly termed as checks and balances. The government is divided into two sections: National and State. Each section is then separated into three different branches: Legislative, Executive, and Judicial. Each branch is a distinct department with different abilities according to the people. "Hence a double security arises to the rights of the people. The different governments will control each other, at the same time that each will be controlled by itself" (Ferderalist No. 51).

This paradox creating a seemingly unstable society has created one of the most powerful societies known to man because not only does it give power to the government, but it also gives power to the people to rule it. However, for this to truly work, the Founding Fathers had to create a document outlining the details and the abilities said government. Madison's solution to this predicament is the U.S. Constitution. In essence, the Constitution creates a list of ''dos" for the government and in addition to this, the Amendments create a list of "don'ts." All powers not given to the National government are directly handed to the states and by default, the people. This creates another "double security" in the system: the people rule both the National and State governments and in turn, both governments rule the people by the power given by the people.

Not only does the Constitution create a powerful nation, it in itself shows the power that "we the people" have. The document is a direct example of "primary control" and the government it has created shows the effectiveness of "auxiliary precautions." It is the solution to the attempts of men atempting to create a system of government rulled by the people giving liberty to those it governs.

Friday, October 7, 2011

The Inspiration of the United State's Constitution

When in discussion of the U.S. Constitution, there is a big controversy among historians over whether or not it was inspired by God. Those that believe it wasn’t would argue that everything that happened was mere coincidence. However, I do not believe in coincidences and will be taking the opposite side of this argument – the Constitution of the United States was inspired and brought about by the hand of God. To better explore this argument, two questions must be answered: How was the Constitution inspired and what about it was inspired.
First, how was the Constitution inspired? When reading in the Doctrine and Covenants 101: 77 & 80, you read that the Constitution is written according to God’s “just and holy principles” and that He has “established the Constitution of this land, by the hands of wise men whom I raised up unto this very purpose.” From a LDS standpoint, this Constitution was inspired by God from the beginning of the Founding Fathers’ lives. But inspiration went far beyond that. When it came to actually writing the Constitution it was a miracle in itself that the authors were able to meet. When it came to sustaining it, it was another miracle that it was actually sustained. Had just one person decided to vote against it, we would not have the Constitution we have today.
Second, what about the Constitution was inspired? In the preamble it states, “in Order to form a more perfect Union.” Order, perfection and unity are three of God’s divine principles of the eternities. “Life, liberty and … happiness,” are three more. In the first sentence of the Constitution, it already states six principles of God and the eternities. How could this have simply come into being by coincidence when these six words are thrown in your face right at the beginning of the Constitution? Is there any more evidence needed that this work was inspired by the hand of God than this alone?

Thursday, September 29, 2011

The Moral Foundation for the American Struggle for Independence

When asked about the American Revolution, most Americans believe the colonists to be justified in their revolts. Some would even go as far as to say that if you didn't believe it that you were "un-American" and not loyal to your country. However, what most people don't seem to realize is that what they are judging the colonists' actions by is a government that did not exist at that time. The question then becomes were the colonists morally justified in their struggle for independence?
There are several arguments that I could like to cover in this essay: first, the argument of the rule of law; second, the argument of natural law; third, taxation without representation. There are also three acts that I could like to cover and those are the stamp, sugar and tea acts. Each play a significant role in the revolution of the colonists and set the stage for what was happening.
First, the argument of the rule of law. When laws are set by the government, especially in those governments of monarchy or dictatorship, the ruler often sees himself as above the set law. The statement “he is the king and can do whatever he wants” has been quoted many times in different movies. However, this is incorrect. In a land where the government is chosen by the people and controlled by the people, even a place where the people are not in control of their government, no one is above the law. King George III was seen to be one of those kings that believed that he was above the law and could then tax others in any way he saw fit. This was a major issue with not only the law of the colonies, but also the law of the British constitution. The colonists were not given the rights of either law they were subject to, and the king decided that he was above the only law that could subject him.
Second, the argument of natural law. In the Declaration of Independence, it is stated that all men have the rights to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” Those rights are the things that all men have and that no one else has the right to infringe upon. You cannot take something from someone that they do not give you the right to do. You can only give those rights to other that you yourself has the right to do. One excellent example of this is the right to protect yourself. Another is taxation without representation. When the sugar, stamp and tea acts went into effect, the big conflict had two issues: the taxes were too high and taxation without representation. We will discuss the latter.
Third, taxation without representation.  Every act that was enacted upon the colonists was used to raise revenue and increase the power of the British Isles. This was another really big controversy between the two governments. The colonists felt they were being oppressed and abused because of the things that the British government was enforcing on them.
When King Georg III came into power, he became a lot more aggressive with the colonists. The kings preceding him were seen as being weak and too tolerant of the Whigs and the actions of the colonists. He fired the Whigs and brought the parliament back into power. To create greater loyalty among his subjects, he gave people government positions and created more in the military to control the colonists. He was able to hit two birds with one stone: create control over the government and greater loyalty through his subjects.
All of these things created great conflict and increased the tension. If King George III had been less aggressive and had some restraint for himself, he might have been able to keep the colonies under control. We may even still be part of the Isles today if his actions hadn’t gotten out of hand. The same thing can be said for the colonists. Had they not been so resistant towards the British government before King George III came into power, we might have had a lot easier of a time becoming independent of British rule. Not only that, but had the British government not created economic hardships in the Americas, the British economy might not have fallen and taken such a huge toll on both sides.
However, as history stands, all these actions led up to the revolution. They were morally justified in resisting the British government because first, the rule of law was violated because those in power, particularly King George III, did not conform to his own laws and ruled himself above them. Second, there was not just a violation, but a massive violation of the natural law of mankind. No one can infringe, partially or wholly, upon anyone else’s rights. The only thing that is acceptable by many people is the ability to give certain responsibilities from yourself to others in your stead. The colonists gave no such right to the king or the British government. Third, taxation without representation was a major wrung on the ladder to the revolution. Had the taxes not been so steep and the Acts fewer in number, the colonists might not have resisted to the extent that they did.
Had the British government had actual reasons for Acts and had not had such a hard fist and made life so miserable for the colonists, perhaps the revolution would never have happened and the life that people live today would be entirely different. The history of the last two hundred years would be changed. Other countries would not have become free. World War I and II would have most likely had a different outcome. September 11, 2001 might never have happened and the war we have been in for the past ten years might never have occurred. Thousands of lives might have been saved. And reversely, millions of lives most likely would have been lost. The revolution created such a huge effect, history would not be the same and the liberties enjoyed today, many might not have.