When asked about the American Revolution, most Americans believe the colonists to be justified in their revolts. Some would even go as far as to say that if you didn't believe it that you were "un-American" and not loyal to your country. However, what most people don't seem to realize is that what they are judging the colonists' actions by is a government that did not exist at that time. The question then becomes were the colonists morally justified in their struggle for independence?
There are several arguments that I could like to cover in this essay: first, the argument of the rule of law; second, the argument of natural law; third, taxation without representation. There are also three acts that I could like to cover and those are the stamp, sugar and tea acts. Each play a significant role in the revolution of the colonists and set the stage for what was happening.
First, the argument of the rule of law. When laws are set by the government, especially in those governments of monarchy or dictatorship, the ruler often sees himself as above the set law. The statement “he is the king and can do whatever he wants” has been quoted many times in different movies. However, this is incorrect. In a land where the government is chosen by the people and controlled by the people, even a place where the people are not in control of their government, no one is above the law. King George III was seen to be one of those kings that believed that he was above the law and could then tax others in any way he saw fit. This was a major issue with not only the law of the colonies, but also the law of the British constitution. The colonists were not given the rights of either law they were subject to, and the king decided that he was above the only law that could subject him.
Second, the argument of natural law. In the Declaration of Independence, it is stated that all men have the rights to “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” Those rights are the things that all men have and that no one else has the right to infringe upon. You cannot take something from someone that they do not give you the right to do. You can only give those rights to other that you yourself has the right to do. One excellent example of this is the right to protect yourself. Another is taxation without representation. When the sugar, stamp and tea acts went into effect, the big conflict had two issues: the taxes were too high and taxation without representation. We will discuss the latter.
Third, taxation without representation. Every act that was enacted upon the colonists was used to raise revenue and increase the power of the British Isles. This was another really big controversy between the two governments. The colonists felt they were being oppressed and abused because of the things that the British government was enforcing on them.
When King Georg III came into power, he became a lot more aggressive with the colonists. The kings preceding him were seen as being weak and too tolerant of the Whigs and the actions of the colonists. He fired the Whigs and brought the parliament back into power. To create greater loyalty among his subjects, he gave people government positions and created more in the military to control the colonists. He was able to hit two birds with one stone: create control over the government and greater loyalty through his subjects.
All of these things created great conflict and increased the tension. If King George III had been less aggressive and had some restraint for himself, he might have been able to keep the colonies under control. We may even still be part of the Isles today if his actions hadn’t gotten out of hand. The same thing can be said for the colonists. Had they not been so resistant towards the British government before King George III came into power, we might have had a lot easier of a time becoming independent of British rule. Not only that, but had the British government not created economic hardships in the Americas, the British economy might not have fallen and taken such a huge toll on both sides.
However, as history stands, all these actions led up to the revolution. They were morally justified in resisting the British government because first, the rule of law was violated because those in power, particularly King George III, did not conform to his own laws and ruled himself above them. Second, there was not just a violation, but a massive violation of the natural law of mankind. No one can infringe, partially or wholly, upon anyone else’s rights. The only thing that is acceptable by many people is the ability to give certain responsibilities from yourself to others in your stead. The colonists gave no such right to the king or the British government. Third, taxation without representation was a major wrung on the ladder to the revolution. Had the taxes not been so steep and the Acts fewer in number, the colonists might not have resisted to the extent that they did.
Had the British government had actual reasons for Acts and had not had such a hard fist and made life so miserable for the colonists, perhaps the revolution would never have happened and the life that people live today would be entirely different. The history of the last two hundred years would be changed. Other countries would not have become free. World War I and II would have most likely had a different outcome. September 11, 2001 might never have happened and the war we have been in for the past ten years might never have occurred. Thousands of lives might have been saved. And reversely, millions of lives most likely would have been lost. The revolution created such a huge effect, history would not be the same and the liberties enjoyed today, many might not have.
Amazing! You are a great writer! You covered all of the principles and specifics! Good Job!
ReplyDeleteFantastic essay! You had great structure to your essay. It flowed well and was easy for me to read all of the way through. You made great points and had good historical backing as well. Good work!
ReplyDeletethis was a wonderfully written essay. you made your points clear and your paper flowed from topic to topic really nicely. i also really like how you put somewhat of a modern twist at the end showing that the events leading up to American independence is really retentive to today. anyways nice essay good use of examples! good job!!
ReplyDelete