When in discussion of the U.S. Constitution, there is a big controversy among historians over whether or not it was inspired by God. Those that believe it wasn’t would argue that everything that happened was mere coincidence. However, I do not believe in coincidences and will be taking the opposite side of this argument – the Constitution of the United States was inspired and brought about by the hand of God. To better explore this argument, two questions must be answered: How was the Constitution inspired and what about it was inspired.
First, how was the Constitution inspired? When reading in the Doctrine and Covenants 101: 77 & 80, you read that the Constitution is written according to God’s “just and holy principles” and that He has “established the Constitution of this land, by the hands of wise men whom I raised up unto this very purpose.” From a LDS standpoint, this Constitution was inspired by God from the beginning of the Founding Fathers’ lives. But inspiration went far beyond that. When it came to actually writing the Constitution it was a miracle in itself that the authors were able to meet. When it came to sustaining it, it was another miracle that it was actually sustained. Had just one person decided to vote against it, we would not have the Constitution we have today.
Second, what about the Constitution was inspired? In the preamble it states, “in Order to form a more perfect Union.” Order, perfection and unity are three of God’s divine principles of the eternities. “Life, liberty and … happiness,” are three more. In the first sentence of the Constitution, it already states six principles of God and the eternities. How could this have simply come into being by coincidence when these six words are thrown in your face right at the beginning of the Constitution? Is there any more evidence needed that this work was inspired by the hand of God than this alone?
Good job on your essay. You gave really good examples and made great points. I think you could have expanded a little more on some of the, but it still was written very well. I really liked the scripture reference that you gave. Good job!
ReplyDeleteNice! I think you did a very good job on explaining how the constitution came to be inspired. You included quotes from doctrine, and I enjoyed that as I read your paper. It also showed you put some time into the research. I would have liked however, to see more reasoning as to what about the constitution was inspired. I feel you vaguely touched upon this when you began to explain the preamble to the Constitution. That to me was your opportunity to include some key points and reasons as to really what is inspired about it. For example, separation of powers or the bill of rights could have been great key points to include. Other than my advice on that, you did a nice job!
ReplyDeleteSome of your facts need checking/clarifying. Is there a big controversy among historians? What do you mean by “if one person had decided to vote against it, we would not have the constitution we have today”? What do you mean by “this constitution was inspired by God from the beginning of the Founding Father’s lives”? Are you trying to say that the Founding Fathers had been prepared from the beginning of their lives to write the constitution? “Life, Liberty, and …happiness” is a quote from the Declaration of Independence, how does it relate to the subject of this essay? Good closing sentence, but more evidence is, in my opinion, needed.
ReplyDelete